Anyone who has read this column for a while will be
aware I am very much a fan of the Daihatsu Mira (her indoors even owns
one), in fact, I have been a fan of many previous Daihatsu’s - the
Charade being a great pocket rocket fun car, which took off where the Mini
left off.
One of the newest Daihatsu offerings which I believe
will come here is the Daihatsu YRV. Our Down-under correspondent, my old
mate the irascible John Weinthal, has just spent some time with the new
Daihatsu and has come up with an unqualified “Why”, rather than “YRV”.
Here are the Words from Weinthal.
“On hearing that we were to travel by Daihatsu YRV
last weekend a mate suggested that it was odd to name a vehicle with a
question - like, he said, Y RV? He promptly responded to his own thought
saying that it was tempting to come up with an answer. Joking he may well
have been. However, he’d sewn a thought and I couldn’t leave it alone
as the week dragged on.
“Here was a 64 kW, 1.3 litre wagonette with rather
cutesy frontal styling which rapidly deteriorated to near pug-ugly from
the B pillar back - that’s the pillar behind the front seat. It’s one
of the current crazes for high riding, short vehicles with fold-down rear
seats which can also be removed. I am sure they have a purpose - indeed I
did carry a small bookshelf across town - one which I couldn’t slide
into the leather-clad 70 grand Lexus IS 300 a couple of weeks back.
This
Daihatsu was a five door manual gear model and it cost AUD 18,000 - auto
would have added $1800. And that’s the total YRV range - five doors,
manual or auto. And they certainly have showroom appeal with standard air
con, central - but not remote - locking, power mirrors and front and back
windows and decent sized glovebox and door bins.
But the question remained - Y RV? Why this YRV? What
was it for? Was it any good really? Sadly, one concluded just a short
distance down the road that showroom appeal was about all it really did
offer. The ride was crude and crashy. It leaned into corners and really
suggested it would rather proceed in a straight line, thank you very much.
It rattled and buzzed. The engine was more than willing, but contributed
its own racket as you piled on the revs. This car was a blast from a none
too pleasant past.
However, it was some time since I had driven others of
its kind. The recent Holden (Chevrolet here) Zafira was in quite a
different price class - and offered seven seats even if three were best
suited to kids.
No, I had to recall some from the past - and one I
hadn’t tried. For many thousand dollars less I recalled the Daewoo Matiz.
Just three cylinders and 800cc, but I remember it as a real car; one to
enjoy both as driver and for its practicality and features list.
Toyota’s Echo (AKA Yaris) is another of the
high-riding brigade but it doesn’t really fit the wagonette theme, and
it is heaps more expensive for a car I remember as feeling pretty
lightweight and most unToyotalike.
Then there was a car I hadn’t driven. A call to
Suzuki saw me in the closest thing to the YRV there is, even though it
undercuts it pricewise by around a grand. I borrowed the Suzuki Ignis for
a day just to see how wrong I might have been about the YRV. Perhaps I’d
had too many over 50 grand lushmobiles lately. Sorry, Daihatsu. I was
right - so I still say Y RV, and say no to the YRV.
The Ignis felt like a real grown up car. It had a
degree of refinement the YRV made no effort to aspire to. It went around
corners happily, and wasn’t badly upset by the sort of suburban ruts and
bumps which had the YRV thudding and bumping along.
I still question whether these crossover wagon/cars
will really catch on, but am in no doubt that the best of them all - and
easily the most expensive is the Holden (Chevrolet) Zafira with the Ignis
probably second to the smaller Daewoo Matiz.
Sorry Daihatsu. This YRV is best left in the showroom.
Well done Suzuki - now, start telling the world more about your Ignis.