The Story of Stuff by Annie Leonard (ISBN 978-1-4516-1029-1, Free Press, 2011) attracted my eye on the Bookazine shelves in Big C Extra, being personally so conversant with the “stuff” at home. I should have looked further or read the sub-title at least, “The impact of over-consumption on the planet, our communities, and our health - and how we can make it better.”
Annie Leonard, it turns out, is a professional “greenie”, having been an employee of Greenpeace before becoming one of Ralph Nader’s raiders, then a member of the Global Alliance for Incineration Alternatives, Healthcare without harm and the Sustainability Funders. This being the case, I began reading with some trepidation.
Right from the beginning of the Introduction it was obvious that Annie Leonard is an excellent writer, as the words flow smoothly, but also obvious that Ms Leonard bases part of her thrust in the trust that CO2 emissions must not go above 350 parts per million (ppm) because “leading scientists” have said so. That’s my first stumbling block. These “leading scientists” seem to be able to pull numbers out of a hat, or rather, out of the air. With CO2 making up 0.03 percent of the earth’s atmosphere, so with 99.97 percent left, I wonder if Ms Leonard is taking us up a rather uncharted road?
Don’t go looking for solace in a cup of coffee, the book suggests that it takes 36 gallons of water to make one cup of coffee and 256 gallons to make a T-shirt. I felt that I was about to be singled out as the producer of drought.
And, profligate that I am, I regularly drink water, adding to the six-fold increase in consumption in the last century, I am informed. Mind you, how anyone can come up with figures for consumption 100 years ago, I do not know. But then, I’m not green.
A Utopian future is suggested by us showing “status” by kindness, experience and wisdom, rather than a flashy car. I doubt I will see that in my lifetime.
I am also sure that some of Ms. Leonard’s ideas are based on good science, but unfortunately not practical.
At the back of the book are several pages of acknowledgments including a group who had resisted oil and coal extraction throughout the world, this being a plus in Ms. Leonard’s eyes. There is also a sample letter you can use and send to any manufacturer of PVC products, because of the toxicity involved. I’m sorry, I am still happy to buy my sandwiches in film.
At B. 495 this book is exciting reading for the dedicated green people. Last time I looked while in the shower, I remained a healthy pink color, despite my sandwiches. I’m sorry, but The Story of Stuff failed to win a convert here.